Pages

Showing posts sorted by relevance for query reading. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query reading. Sort by date Show all posts

Friday, August 3, 2012

My Students are Geniuses...and I Can't Wait to Meet my New Ones!

I teach a class called Reading for Pleasure...based loosely on a readers workshop approach with everyone reading self-selected books every day. It's a semester elective at my high school, Norman North High School. Because I'm a National Writing Project Teacher Consultant, we also write every day. That's it.We read. We write. Sometimes we talk to each other about our books and listen to new book recommendations. It takes a huge leap of faith to believe a room full of high school students WILL sit quietly and read, and then write. I never doubted they could, but we had lots of critics who have called the class a glorified study hall, or a blow-off, or a wasted elective.

So, I often ask my students to reflect (a result of my own National Board Certification) on their own learning. My final exam is all essay...long answers get the best grades, and self-reflection is required. I read all these answers and collect the responses.

This spring, I copied some of the more interesting comments and will be sharing them here...I always tell my students one of my missions in life is to prove to the world how brilliant they are. So, today I'm sharing the responses that address students' changes in their attitudes about reading, and their insights into skills enhancement.

Disclaimer...I didn't change minor grammatical differences...I wanted the flavor of my students' writing to shine.


  • A few things I’ve gotten out or reading is that you can learn life lessons before you even have to go through them. If a situation comes up you will already know how to go about it.
  • Before I took this class I thought I hated reading in general and thought it was stupid, as most kids do. But…I have actually read the books we have to read in English and am now willing to give books a chance.
  • Before I took this class reading literally meant nothing to me. This semester has changed my reading. This class basically taught me to like reading…if I can find the right book
  • Before R4P I only read when I was required to read, or when I was grounded. But now, I read every chance I get especially when I’m stressed, because I feel able to let everything go and fully engage in my book.
  • Books create a new, different world for readers. Reading distracts us from reality
  • Each book I’ve read has [a]ffected me in a different way, but each has left its mark
  • Every time I would read I would never look at the clock, never drifting off into space, and I would never want to stop reading. It is safe to say I got lost in these books. Sometimes I would forget I was in class because I could visualize everything that was happening in the books
  • Everything I’ve read has pushed me to be a better reader and better student this semester
  • I am a stronger and more confident reader than I ever was. There is so much I feel like I have accomplished.
  • I am much more of a reader than I used to be
  • I am really proud of myself because I would‘ve never thought I would like to read or read this many books
  • I believe all books stick with you to some degree. That’s the beauty of it all.
  • I believe R4P will and has changed so many kids’ outlooks on reading
  • I can actually do anything I set my mind to
  • I can love to read if I find the right books.
  • I can now sit longer and read for a long period of time. I get spelling and grammar a lot better because of reading
  • I can read faster and like bigger, more intense books
  • I can sit down and read for much longer. I’ve become a stronger reader
  • I could read faster and after I’m done reading I could tell you word from word what the book was about.
  • I do slow down and actually read…and I question more than I used to
  • I even found myself searching for deeper meaning when I watched Wall-E in Statistics today. It’s actually amazing how many allusions to literature that movie made.
  • I feel accomplished that I got to read books that after I read them I felt like it was a good thing I read them
  • I feel I can be whatever I want to, just like Cupcake Brown
  • I feel like I’m actually in the story and sometimes it’s hard to focus back on real life
  • I finished two books per month. Now when I get bored, I always pull out a book and start reading.
  • I found a new relaxation in reading, which I think adapts to us all as we get older
  • I get a lot more out of reading now and I realized I’m not a terrible reader like I originally thought
  • I get a mini-movie playing in my head and enjoyment that I can be doing something interesting.
  • I get an incredible sense of self through reading. By analyzing foreign characters and situations I see more and more of myself
  • I hated reading, it bored me. I was never comfortable. I didn’t think I was a good reader. But taking this class really helped me oversee how I really was and look at how I am now
  • I have been paying attention to the stories not myself
  • I have grown to expand my horizon in reading and let others influence what I read….it’s good to pick out your own books..but I love someone else giving you a book and sharing what they got from it.
  • I have improved as a reader by being able to stick with books when at first they seem boring to me.
  • I have learned to read different kinds of book and longer books
  • I have slowed down when reading and am more willing to ask questions
  • I have stepped out of my comfort zone by reading harder and longer books with bigger words.
  • I like reading books and like writing about what I have read.
  • I love being pulled into stories and getting to feel love and pain and friendship and lust and all of the other emotions in life. They let me enter another reality over and over again
  • I love reading about other people’s lives and struggles and accomplishments.
  • I LOVE to read now, and every book is a good book. I’ve encouraged my friends to read and even recommended books, which is something I’ve never done
  • I never gave reading the time of day…
  • I never thought I liked reading and never read (even for school…bad I know) but after this class I have discovered I do love reading I just needed to know what to read
  • I now take the time to think about a character’s decision, and why an even happened in a book
  • I read faster and it is easier for me to comprehend books and characters and also it has gotten me smarter in class.
  • I read faster now. I read some books I’ve wanted to read a long time
  • I read faster, more, and I feel I can comprehend better as well.
  • I really like reading. I just had to find that book I REALLY like to be able to read it
  • I really need to focus when I read; not just speed through a book to get to the end. I tend to really get a life-lesson out of the books I read then the books for entertainment
  • I reestablished my relationship with words in this class, and that has improved my writing as well. I am proud that my time in here has helped me grow as a person
  • I started out with it taking me about two weeks to finish Dear John, but by the second month I had read two books in one week!
  • I stepped out of my comfort zone by reading classics. It was hard to get into them at first but now I can’t read modern novels without thinking how casual the writing sounds
  • I stepped out of my comfort zone in reading by reading when I’m at home, telling people about the books I’ve read or am reading, and by making my friends read a book I think is good
  • I think about the books I read as I read them and I reflect more on them
  • I think everybody needs to be a reader
  • I used to barely read, now I read constantly
  • I’ll continue to read as long as I have the thirst to learn and be entertained by stories.
  • I’m going to practice keeping a personal reading log this summer! My friend can call me a dork. I don’t care.
  • I’m proud of being a bookworm!
  • I’m proud of myself for embracing reading and branching out to new genres.
  • I’m proud that I’ve read more books this semester than in the last 2-1/2 years put together
  • I’m so happy I’ve become a better and faster reader. Reading is so peaceful. It calms me down a lot. Reading this semester has made me want me read more during college next year and this summer.
  • I’ve become a faster and more aware reader. I consider characters more carefully and find ways to relate to them.
  • I’ve become more tolerant of books I don’t enjoy. I’ve started reflecting more thoroughly and more often. My reading and writing skills have both improved
  • I’ve certainly appreciated the extra hour a day for reading
  • I’ve gotten more attached to reading and love having a new book
  • I’ve learned that I need a fair amount of action or constant change in a book to stay really engaged.
  • I’ve read more books this semester than compared to the rest of my high school career.
  • I’ve stepped out of my comfort zone simply by reading.
  • If someone has asked me six months ago what reading meant to me I would have honestly said nothing. But now I can sea to me reading is so much fun.
  • If you are a person like I was and did not like to read, you NEED this class. This class was so much help for me as a person and a student.
  • If…I wasn’t forced to read a certain book, but just ANY book, then I think I would have started reading a long time ago
  • My favorite genre to discover this year was the character-driven books
  • My habits as a reader have gone from picky and proud to free and relaxed
  • My reading habits have changed from zero books a year to 15 in 18 weeks, so that ‘s a pretty good difference.
  • Now each book I’ve read, I’ve stepped out of my comfort zone
  • Now I have started reading at home more.
  • Now I look forward to reading every day.
  • Now that I’ve taken R4P I have an excuse to read. And it drives my mother nuts when I neglect my part of chores for a book. But that’s a sacrifice I’m willing to make.
  • R4P has given me the ability to read longer and absorb more from the books at the same time. It has shown me how much I actually do get distracted when I read and helped me learn to keep myself focused.  It gives readers more endurance
  • R4P has helped me pay attention in class reading books more easily. This class helped me realize that it’s not about how fast you read, It’s about what you learned about your books.
  • R4P has helped me with my disability in reading in so many ways. I know I can read out loud better, read faster and comprehend things better than I used to.
  • R4P has showed me I am capable of being a good, fast reader
  • R4P has shown me I’m a distracted reader. My mind wanders and I read without thinking, if that makes sense. Reading makes me think more, though.
  • R4P has shown me that the more pages I read, the better of a reader I am
  • R4P helped my vocabulary…I really do love to read and it opens my creativity. I get to explore my mind with reading
  • R4P showed me reading isn’t boring, I was simply choosing the wrong books such as ones I judged by the cover, by the length, etc. So R4P has taught me to ask about a book
  • R4P…[taught] me to be still, well-seated for a long period of time. Even when I’m seated I’m not still, I rock myself for some reason or I bounce my legs. R4P has also helped me by keeping focused. I’ve expanded my horizon
  • Reading and writing your logs helps you out so you can talk and understand your books
  • Reading gave me good advice and life lessons. It helps my reading comprehension and writing
  • Reading gives me pleasure, makes me smarter and more sophisticated , develops and informs my life philosophy and broadens my horizons                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        
  • Reading is what keeps me going. It sustains me much more so than pedantic lectures or monoliths from text books
  • Reading to me is a big priority. I never was much of a reader but [R4P] has now opened my eyes to reading and going outside my box. I regret not taking this class sooner.
  • Reading used to be something I “had” to do. After taking this class I can say I enjoy reading a lot more than I did
  • Since R4P, my concentration level when it comes to reading has greatly increased. I am able to pay more attention and actually soak in what I read or hear
  • Sometimes I’ll just sit and think about my books for a while, what twists could be coming up, how this will end…
  • Thanks for turning me on to a great book. The most important class I ever took in high school
  • The more poetry I read the more I like it and the better I get at staying focused on it for longer periods of time
  • The way I relate to books is through emotion, trying to put myself in the book so I can try to see what they are going through…
  • This class forced me to take an interest in literature and it has become the kickstart to a career of reading
  • This class has made me love reading again. I have my summer booklist and I cannot wait to start them
  • This class has showed me that I love reading and hopefully I will always have a book with me from now on
  • This class has shown me I can be a very good reader if you give me a good book to read
  • This class has shown me that I am a real reader because I have bought books and looked for books to read next
  • This class has shown me writing style means a lot to me. I get knowledge and entertainment out of reading. It takes me away.
  • When I need to get away from reality, I can go into the world of my book. Get away from pain and be  a character in the book; sometimes it is easier to go through their problems than my own.
  • With reading I get sent to new places, meet new people and learn valuable life lessons
  • You can accomplish anything if you try hard enough
Now you know why I'm so proud of them!

Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Reading Growth Through My Students' Eyes

As I continue to reflect on my students' final exams, and learn from them, I come to the question that I wasn't sure about when the kids wrote it: What does reading mean and has that changed? If I can predict what they'll say, I worry about the value of the question, and I knew the definition would be positive, and for some students, that would show a change...But as I read, and as I thought back on the changes in their attitudes in just 18 weeks, I'm glad the question is there. This question wasn't for me -- it was for them. They wanted to think about and talk about what reading means to them now.

I've said before, my class is not made up of omnivorous readers, although I do have some avid book-enhalers. My class is a true mixed bag, and I think that's part of the strength. Kids have remarked about how many different students take my class...trouble-makers, perfect students, ELL students, good kids who never give teachers trouble. They're all here. Kids who haven't read a book ever, haven't read since elementary. Kids who have fake-read their way through high school, buying Cliffs Notes and calling it good. They're all here.

One boy wrote me a note about his plans for class: he was going to find a friend to join him in making merry -- disrupting class, talking, kicking back and visiting. He was shocked and dismayed to discover, as he sat pretending to read, that everyone else was engaged in his or her book. He couldn't catch eyes with anyone. He told me he reluctantly started to read his own book and never looked back.

Another girl explained she loved my class because of the democratic nature of it. Other electives self-select students so kids don't get a chance to be with different kinds of students. Here, I've had a tough guy who, when he slapped The Contender closed for the last time, announced with pride that was the first book he'd ever read. It's not too often that he's in a class with National Merit Scholars, cheers and poms, foreign exchange students, college-bound students...all together, all supportive, but all independently pursuing goals, independently reading and writing.The common task of reading gives us all a sense of community and we all respect the differences in our identities at North.

Students are able to take the class more than one time, and some kids try to minor in R4P.  We pitched this change because in a second or third semester, students will be reading new books, facing new comprehension challenges. Since the curriculum is set by students' choices of books and my responding to them, taking the class over is highly beneficial. It is to the climate of my class, too. The returning students know the drill...they act as role models, almost co-teachers in many ways. Their leadership helps us coalesce as a class much faster..

Students do define reading very differently at the beginning of the semester and the end. Words I've heard at the beginning of the semester are: boring, a chore, required, something they're forced to do, hard...I could go on, but the picture is clear These are NOT the eager children they were in their first grade classes, knowing their job was to learn to read. Some have become distracted by other activities, but some have become so beaten down...they've lost hope that there's a book out there for them.

Many kids come to my class assuming it's going to be one more way for the school to prove to them they're not strong, not good enough.They're afraid I'm going to show their weaknesses to the world.  I try to encourage with words, but it's got to be the books that change their minds, about their own strengths and attitudes, and about books. Every book they read, they're stronger readers and more confident readers.

So, as their attitudes, experiences, abilities are so different, their definitions of reading are as well. But a semester of positive, successful encounters with books does make its mark. They have grown as readers, and they can articulate that fact. They're eager to talk about their growth. We can see it in their answer to the question:  What does reading mean to you? How has that changed this semester?


  • Reading actually means a lot to me now. I read when I’m stressed and I need to cool down. I read for entertainment, I read for information. I read to enrich my vocabulary. The list just keeps going
  • Reading has always been a core, but now it’s a hobby that I love I will now be a reader for life!
  • Reading is a glimpse into the collective human consciousness
  • Reading is a way for me to learn about people and subject I am interested in, as well as to be entertained every once in a while
  • Reading is a way to go on an adventure.
  • Reading is an escape for me. I love watching what an author can pull together to make a story.
  • Reading makes me feel like I’m in a whole new other world, looking at something from a different perspective.
  • Reading means a lot to me because it helps us escape the problems we’re dealing with and find pleasure.
  • Reading means exploring the unknown to me.
  • Reading means I can step out of the ordinary and into the extraordinary. Explore what would happen if, for instance, a clown jumped from the ferris wheel over a shark-infested ocean and become friends with the sharks, learned their habits and mated with one!
  • Reading means learning about others without even talking to them because you can relate to them; it means I can go to Africa while in the bath tub. It means I can hear how someone else dealt with what I’m going through. Reading means I can share knowledge with others and I love that.
  • Reading means learning to me. Reading used to be boring but now I have found good books. I can do whatever I set my mind to
  • Reading means more to me now than it did before I had this class.
  • Reading means the key to knowledge for me because you learn so much from one book
  • Reading means to be in a huge fictional world
  • Reading means to me that I’ve accomplished something. I read better and understand things in class
  • Reading to me is a new-found glory.
  • Reading to me is a way to inhabit worlds and fantasies where anything is possible. Where magic is rea and the good guy always wins.
  • Reading to me is educational, inspiring, distracting, comforting, fun and entertaining. Not only do I read faster, but I understand more. I get more emotionally attached
  • Reading to me is like meditation. All of your worries in life are swept away by a new world. I get a sort of meditating sensation out of reading
  • Reading used to be something that was forced upon me at times and something that was dreaded. Now reading is something that is fun and that I do as my choice instead of ‘having’ to read
  • Reading used to just be something for me to do. Now, it has grown to be an escape, a way to cope, a way to find answers to life’s questions or whatever I need ti to be
  • To me reading is a gateway to another world
  • To me reading means escaping this world to enter a new one. At the beginning of the semester, all reading meant to me was opening a book and reading the words. 



 

Sunday, August 19, 2012

We Read for Pleasure, but We Accidentally Learn

From the first day of my Reading for Pleasure class (initially called 'Appreciating Literature' since I was afraid to call the class what it really is), I have been blessed with administrators who understood what I was doing, or at least trusted me to understand what I was doing. No one has ever suggested I do pre-and post-tests, proving students are better readers at the end of the semester. No one has insisted that I show 'results', demand that all students read the same number of books, or the same number of pages. At the beginning, I just wanted to show that a class where students were giving the freedom to choose which books to read would impact their attitudes about reading and their own perception of themselves as readers.

I've given reading tests for 30 years, and I know most students don't understand the results. What, exactly, does the number 8.6 tell us about their reading? They DO understand if they read more slowly than the other students in class, or if they realize in discussions their understanding of the book is incomplete. They know if they can read all the words in the assigned texts -- and if they can't, they go into panic mode, spending their energies on trying to hide their inadequacies from their classmates and their teachers. They know reading can trip them up all through their day. These are the students I hoped will come away with a new perception of their strengths and their developing capabilities.

I didn't intend for my class to impact students' work outside my walls, but from listening, asking the right questions, and trusting my students to ask questions they want to answer, I've learned much. The benefits of my 'little' elective are far-reaching inside Norman North High School and beyond, in colleges and universities. I help students become 'life long readers' and 'life long learners.' I always wondered what those terms meant -- I now see the transformation begin.

On their final last semester, students wrote a question that addressed impact on other classes. "How has R4P helped you in your other classes? Explain." It wasn't one of the required questions, but many students did choose to speak to the changes they've seen in their work at school because of our class.

The biggest impact students notice is their ability to focus, sit still and pay attention for longer and longer, their willingness to be quiet and be with a book. We don't begin our semester reading for 45 minutes a day. I know many of my students cannot sit that long and focus. This is one of the many ways my students vary wildly in their abilities. Some are used to sitting for hours and reading. Others literally can't focus for five minutes. I talk to them about building their stamina slowly. We break up the class period with other activities, but we read every day. I've had extreme cases where students, usually because of learning difficulties and attention deficits, feel trapped by the quiet in our room. Most of them trust me and work with me. I learned a wonderful strategy to use with such kids and am eager to try. I watched a teacher literally time a student reading for two minutes, giving him a break, and then asking for another two minutes. It was done respectfully and the young man was eager to extend his attention. It doesn't take long for those kids to surface in the classroom, and now I have a new idea to help them extend their stamina.

Most of the students don't use the word 'stamina' but that's what we're building...like a runner, like a swimmer. We need to practice extending the time we can read and focus. Nearly every student who enrolls in the class with a stamina challenge has found the discipline to be quiet and to attend to his or her book for longer and longer amounts of time.

Students also point to increased vocabularies...one father just told me that his nieces and nephews noticed how many more 'big words' his son used in conversations now...a year of R4P exposes students to millions of words, many of them new and many of them big!

As a Teacher Consultant for Oklahoma Writing Project, I understand the connection between reading and writing is important and one I stress. We read and we write. They write to me; I provide an authentic audience who responds. Often I'll have students who already know they want to write as professionals. They know, before I ever tell them that reading makes us better writers. I've had students keep journals of the strong writing they encounter in class. But most students are surprised to discover extensive reading strengthens their writing. It doesn't take them long to make that observation and to attribute it to the reading they do in this class.

I didn't set out to change the culture of our school, but the 300 students who take my class each year go out into their other classes armed with new skills, new strengths, and most of all, new confidences. Can't get any better than that.

But it doesn't end at North. Many students have told me they're taking my class to help prepare them for the rigors of college reading and writing. They know they'll have to be self-directed in reading their assignments, and they'll need that stamina we build. Students return from college to tell me the practice in our class did just that -- helped them sustain their independent work through college.

Through social media, I stay in contact with hundreds of my former students. Yesterday, I had a long exchange with a former student about Hunger Games -- book vs. novel. It's not unusual for former students to ask for book recommendations, or recommend books to me. They send me pictures of their children reading. What we started together in R4P extends into their adult lives.

I've had students who've been inspired to continue their passions for reading and writing, and they've chosen majors in Classics, Literature, Creative Writing, and that makes me proud. I've had other students who tell me as parents they read every day to their children. In some ways, that makes me prouder...we are changing our school and the world with this class.

As usual, I am excited to share my brilliant students' reflections.

  • In English class we read the ‘classic’ novels and every time a book comes around no one in the class likes it and that discourages the students from reading because they think all books are going to be that boring and uninteresting if they are regular readers. But in this class we get to choose what books to read and we can find that there are books that we actually like instead of classics…in response to “We shouldn’t teach great books; we should teach a love of reading” ~B.F. Skinner (and yet the student said Angela’s Ashes was the most inspiring.).
  • APUSH AP US History)  requires a great deal of discipline in order to read 30 pages of a long, dull, and ultimately torturous text book. R4P helped me improve my reading time, so I could actually read my text in the time I was given.
  • By taking this class I am now confident in reading in front of others and so proud of reading so many books.
  • I think every student should take this class before they go off to college. I know that I am now more prepared than ever to start college because I can tackle those long hours of just reading
  • I’m convinced that reading thoughtfully and consistently in R4P has improved my writing and my overall creativity
  • I’m more able to concentrate in other books
  • I’ve learned to look out for symbols and figure out their meaning. This has helped with poetry and especially in my AP English class.
  • In English we have to read aloud a lot and when I spend 30-50 minutes in 1st hour listening to characters in my head it can seriously help.
  • In other classes I can now read through long tedious passages. I get to relax and enjoy myself when I read.
  • Our generation never reads anymore and [the administration] wants to keep us reading
  • R4P develops reading/writing skills along with creativity. It also allows students to express themselves through reading
  • R4P has definitely helped me in my early enrollment English classes, just improving my reading and English skills. R4P has shown me that I can really enjoy reading if I have the right book.
  • R4P has helped in other classes by expanding my vocabulary. I actually enjoy reading now.
  • R4P has helped me expand my vocabulary when I’m writing papers for my college composition class
  • R4P has helped me in History because I used to not be able to just sit down and read from cover to cover. Now I can calm down and read for longer periods of time. It has helped in English because we have to do the logs, so now I think more about what the characters are thinking and how their actions are going to affect the future of the story
  • R4P has helped me in my AP European Hisory class because I have been able to read documents faster. R4P has shown me that I am a very good reader. I find that reading is very relaxing and it helps to just sit down and read instead of doing something that stresses me out.
  • R4P has helped me in other classes because I do some sort of reading in every class…I’m able to focus better now. I can pay attention to something that I’m reading for a longer period of time now.
  • R4P has helped me in other classes because now I can come up with a fairly good response over any reading material. It has also shown me that I read A LOT, which is something I’m very proud of. I get extreme entertainment out of reading
  • R4P has helped me in other classes by making me focus and take the time to understand what I am reading or learning about
  • R4P has helped me in other classes by teaching me to try new things even if I don’t like the topic
  • R4P has helped me pay closer attention to directions especially in English. There is always room to improve as a reader and I can make time to read.
  • R4P has helped me stay focused better in my English class and also outside of school when I’m reading things like instructions and what not
  • R4P has increased my reading ability so much that it has impacted my grades. This class has given me the ability to read for a long period of time and comprehend what I’m reading. I now get a great joy from curling up with a good book in the evenings
  • R4P has made me feel smarter in all my classes. It gave me new habits. It made my life feel different like I’m in my books doing crazy adventurous and fun things.
  • R4P helped in my AP English class because I was able to read the passages on the test faster
  • S R4P helped me bear English…I feel like I’m fairly cultured in literature, and that just wouldn’t be true without this class. I feel like I’ve reaped academic rewards from reading and I know it had a large role in how I think and act as a person.
  • R4P honestly helps me to not get bored in my other classes. I’ll finish my work and know that I have something fun to do afterwards
  • R4P isn’t a core class but it truly has helped in every single one of my core classes.
  • Reading makes people smarter->smarter means  more  AP tests, AP classes and higher ACT, SAT, and AP scores-> higher scores reflect well on our school -> good reflection on the school means better reflection on us all and more school funding
  • Reading my chemistry book became easier and faster as the year sent on and that’s the best that I could’ve asked for
  • Spending an entire semester reading will drastically improve your reading speed, and writing the Logs reflecting on what you’ve read increases your writing ability and reading comprehension at the same time. Not to mention your critical thinking skills!
  • The administration…would probably have a riot the size of the state if they did away with R4P
  • This class has been one of the biggest impacts on my life in the four years I have been at NNHS


Monday, May 26, 2014

Myths, Fairy Tales, Fictions...or Lies?

Learning-to-read-reading-to-learn. It’s a myth. Like Loch Ness and Big Foot.
Learning-to-read-reading-to-learn. It’s a fairy tale. Like Little Red Riding Hood.
Learning-to-read-reading-to-learn. It’s fiction. Like Horton Hears a Who and Little House on the Prairie.
 
My mom visited Loch Ness -- no Nessie sighting.
Every time our Governor and State Superintendent of Public Schools talk about reading and books, I begin growling.  I hear them bloviate about reading instruction…and I can’t stay still. I have spent the bulk of my 39-year teaching career working with young readers: beginning readers, struggling readers, reluctant readers. Avid readers, alliterate readers, remedial readers. Confident readers and diffident ones.

In all those years, I met two non-readers. Guess what? Family issues meant they moved constantly, had little supervision in their lives, and too much chaos. One boy, a fourth grader, surely knew his letter sounds. “Cat” became “Kuh-AAA-Tuh” No meaning at all. We got him reading his first book…and he disappeared. Family moved again. The other, a freshman. Had been raised and homeschooled by his grandmother who finally got tired of his defiance and sent him to school…for the first time in his life. Again, just as we started getting a handle on his strengths and weaknesses… and he was gone.

I don’t know why I’m surprised when the Governor and Superintendent ignore education research, best practices, good teaching, when making their political points. They were dead-set against HB2625, which will now allow a team to make a unanimous decision to promote a 3rd grader who failed the infamous Reading/English Language Arts test now required. That’s all this law (man, that sounds awesome!) will do. Western Civilization is not destroyed. A parent, the child’s teacher, a teacher from the next grade, a principal, and a reading specialist can now sit down together and decide what’s best for a child. The vote must be unanimous to promote. Then the Superintendent must approve. A parent cannot veto the vote. There will be no ‘social promotion’ – another phrase that makes me quiver.

But to support their opposition to this team, they, once again, pulled out ‘Learning-to-read-reading-to-learn.’ as the reason we can’t trust a team of professionals and parents. “In 1st through 3rd, children learn to read; then they read to learn,” they parroted. Children must be retained, without parent input until the state, on a test that can’t measure either learning to read or reading to learn, has its pound of flesh. In the name of ‘learning to read.’

All it took was a 30-second Google search to find numerous links to prove this is a myth, a fairy tale, a fiction. Writers for ASCD, a respected professional development organization, traces the phrase back to educator Jean Chall in the 1990’s. I was surprised that the phrase was invented so recently…I’m sure I’d heard it before then. But there it is…1990.  Scholastic, another respected site, also agrees that this simplistic myth hides the real complexity of reading and reading instruction. My search also led me to Dr. Kimberly Tyson, a literacy expert. I share her deep frustration with adults who are not literacy professionals weighing into the discussion, exposing their ignorance. She cringes when uninformed people use the phrase; at this point, I grind my teeth.

The truth is, we are constantly learning to read, and hopefully, we’re reading to learn. Taking in information and making some kind of sense. Predicting, testing, questioning, confirming or correcting. There is continuous interplay between reading and learning.  Every time we pick up something to read we are learning. A menu, a brochure, a classic novel, a popular novel, nonfiction, a manual, directions, a magazine.

As we are learning to read constantly, so should we be reading to learn. Students need to be reading important pieces from the very first day of reading instruction. They should be reading pieces that have something to say, pieces that make them think and wonder and ask questions. The adults in their lives should be inviting them into the reading club, the club that knows reading is important work.


I’m well past ‘senior citizen’ status and I never stop learning to read; I never stop reading to learn. To say any different, with the surety of our leaders, as often as they say it, does not make it so. It’s still a myth. And repeating it makes it impossible to move forward, finding the best ways to assist every one of our students in learning to read and reading to learn.

Now that I'm retired, I volunteered all school year in my granddaughter’s elementary library. I watched the eagerness of the readers who returned books so they could check out more. I watched their choices. I talked to them about their favorites. They loved nonfiction: books about wolves and sharks. Books about world records and cooking. Books about science experiments. These children, on their own time, were choosing to read to learn.  They also spoke passionately about picture books and novels.  Even preschool babies were coming into the library with a stack of books, and leaving with another. I know the novelty of borrowing books was part of the appeal, but so were the words, the magic of the words.


With every book we read, we learned something about reading and the world. That’s the magic of reading.

I have a radical suggestion for our Governor and our Superintendent: if you truly want to support the literacy learning (reading and learning) of our children, support school libraries. Make certain they have the funds to buy new books, to replace beloved books that fall apart from devotion. Staff the school libraries with professionals and aides. Make sure the libraries are open all day every day. Make sure the library media center is the center and the heart of the school.  I saw that this year…lessons, books, the principal doing a lunch-read-aloud. Students coming in with their library pass to get more. Gentle negotiations with the librarian to promise to find those books that are still checked out so more can be taken home.

I also volunteered at my Big’s middle school and watched the process continue. Passionate conversations about books, students who come to the library to read and to learn. A professional librarian who supported both with love and knowledge. What a pleasure it was to watch the magic that happens in school libraries.

In 2012, SB1443 allowed strapped schools to divert funding from their libraries and use the money for other needed services…That means in some districts, no money has been invested in buying new books, and making sure there are certified library media specialists full time in libraries. It was a cynical move to force schools to prioritize their work. I know in Norman schools, the citizens have approved school bonds, and that is how we have new books. The money is allocated in October and must be spent by October. Other districts don’t have that kind of support, and that means no new books.

Even with the bond money, I know for the last two years I was able to buy (from my own salary) the new releases for my classroom library than our school librarians were. Because I spent my own money, my students did have access to the brand new titles we all love to read. But I paid the bill.


I would love to share research with our Governor and Superintendent. I have a book to suggest they read to learn:  Stephen Krashen, author of The Power of Reading, is clear: strong school libraries support reading for pleasure, for learning, and makes our children stronger, more able readers.


More research shows the same thing: school libraries contribute to higher test scores.  Instead of supporting our libraries and librarians, our state forces districts into a ‘Lady or the Tiger’ choice. The state forces districts to make decisions that contradict good research, in order to survive.


What lots of people don't know about me is I have school library certification, and am a librarian in my heart, as well as a classroom teacher, English teacher, and reading specialist. I feel qualified to share my experience and my research with our leaders.


I hope I don’t hear these myths, fairy tales and fictions from our policy makers any more. I hope they look for ways to support learning to read and reading to learn. Let’s make sure every child in Oklahoma has plenty of books so she can do both: read and learn; learn and read.



Sunday, March 24, 2013

A Review:BOOK LOVE by Penny Kittle -- with only 46 more days left in my career.

Sometimes books find you at an opportune time in your life. This book found me too late...only 46 days left in my career, I find a professional soul-mate I would love to visit with for hours. We share a vision for what schools and teachers should be doing, and yet we came at it from different directions. We had amazing mentors early on: she worked with Don Graves and Don Murray. My teachers at Indiana University included Roger Farr and Carolyn Burke--and her mentor Kenneth Goodman called me his granddaughter. We've learned from the best, and we've both taken those lessons to heart.

We both know relationships are what matter in a classroom. Her stories of nudging students into books, and into more complex books, are fun for me, because I could tell her MY stories too. We know kids need to enjoy their books or they won't read. We both have seen too much 'fake reading' in our careers, and are savvy enough to call kids on it.

I appreciate Kittle's bravery to revamp her traditional Englishclasses to incorporate more pleasure reading...along with the required elements. Close to 20 years ago, my colleagues in my English department all incorporated a reading Friday into our classes. We modeled reading with the kids, and we began work on helping kids select books. But we kept it quiet...kids responded.

I decided more than 10 years ago, that wasn't going to be the route that worked for me, and I 'invented' my current class, Reading for Pleasure. This class allowed me the opportunity to concentrate solely on choice reading, reading for fun, and reflecting on reading. Hearing Kittle talk about her success, I wonder if I bailed too soon from the traditional English classes....I know our 9th and 10 grade teachers have students read during class...but not with the intentionality Kittle displays. I really like the combination of reading in class, and the reading homework she assigns. A creative way to add without overwhelming her kids.

I learned new ideas I wish I had the time to incorporate: Reading Break, similar to DEAR...I appreciated her honesty about the teachers and students who tried to subvert the school wide reading. That's kept me from pushing. She admits she teaches at a small high school -- 900, as opposed to the 2400 students we have at my school. More opportunities for resistant teachers and kids. She said her school confronts that by having administrators roam the halls and classrooms during Reading Break, and keeping everyone honest. I like her ideas.

Summer reading AND summer book groups sound awesome. Having school libraries open during the summer to allow students to check out books! Genius.

I'm trying desperately to figure out how to start using her Big Idea Books these last days -- a group of small notebooks, each dedicated to a Universal Theme, in which students can contribute reflections on their books. Kittle says she keeps hers from year to year -- what an amazing idea to connect readers over time...still thinking of how to pull this one off.

There are many ways we work in sync -- we both aim to build stamina and flexibility; we understand the importance of a 'books to read next' list. We both know we must read with our kids, read what they're reading. We both share books with passion. We build relationships with students, knowing that's the door into the books. We are both widely read, in popular books, YAL books, and professional books. We both feel the same frustration with teachers (especially English teachers) who are not readers and writers, who 'cover' a book and assume their job is finished. She highlights several difficult conversations she's had with colleagues who cling to that status quo thinking. I love her courage to confront, and can see she does it with respect and gentleness.

Those long conversations I wish we could have would be focused on some of the ways we diverge: she does conferences; I have students write and provide lots of feedback, carefully crafted to 'listen' in a different way. I read with my students; she does her conferences while they're reading. Because she does her work in the English class, she is able to have students be 'interdependent' readers, and make year-long connections among the books and the canon. 

I had a wonderful epiphany as I was reading. She brings up a concept I've heard of before: Fixed and dynamic thinking...do we believe our intelligence is fixed, and if we don't get something the first time, it's just too bad...and if we don't get something the first time, we just need to try another way. She says to her kids what I've heard my experienced readers say to each other..."You just haven't found the right books yet." I had my students create a sticky-note chart of their attitudes about reading at the beginning of the semester, and then asked students to comment on the data. It was an identifiable pattern from students who'd taken my class more than once, that the kids who 'hate' or 'HATE' reading just needed to find that book. My students understand the dynamic aspects of reading and especially reading for their own pleasure.

Loved this book -- wish it'd found me sooner. Add another book to the list of 'books I wish I'd've written.' Add another author who lets me know I'm on the right path...for 46 more days.

Wednesday, August 8, 2012

What the Heck is Reading for Pleasure??

My school district changed configurations nearly 15 years ago, from a mid-high, high school configuration to a four-year high school one. We changed from two mid-highs serving 9th and 10th graders and a high school for our 11th and 12th graders to two four-year high schools. Both high schools would work on an A-B Block schedule, meaning in a two day span students would take eight-90 minute classes, and teachers taught six in the same span. We knew we would need more elective choices for kids, and we needed to balance the demands of those electives while offering valuable content.

I 'invented' a dream class: Reading for Pleasure, except we couldn't call it THAT. We called it 'Appreciating Literature.' Well, it languished in the course catalog for three years. My principal was not convinced of its academic merit, and he gave other, more familiar electives their chance to grow. But, as happens, one year there weren't enough electives for students to choose among, and at the very last minute something needed to be added. Since I was such a nag, they gave me a chance. I had two sections that first year, one each semester.

I knew I would need to prove the class immediately or risk losing it, so I found ways to conduct a small research project. My question was: "In what ways does Appreciating Literature change students' reading habits and attitudes about reading?" We did surveys, we kept track of pages read, and I asked students at the end of the year to tell me ways their habits and attitudes changed. And change they did.

I had to prove it wasn't a blow-off class, or a glorified study hall. I had to prove real learning, maybe a different kind of learning, was happening in my class. I had to sell the class to my administration, and I had to sell it to my students and their parents. I worked and recruited. My students convinced me to change the name of the class to Reading for Pleasure, R4P. We still get calls from universities checking the transcripts of prospective students, asking if this is a basketweaving class, and the counselors are quick to explain the class.

We grew slowly from those two sections, and now Norman North offers 12 sections a year. I teach R4P full time, and a colleague teaches one more section a semester. When I told one of my former students I would be teaching R4P full time, he wryly observed, "So, you've figured out how to get them to pay you to read full time!" And, yes I have.

I believe there are several important factors to our success: I read with my students. I read every day. I read the books they recommend to me. Occasionally other teachers will teach a single section, and unless they read with the students, they don't have my success. It's tempting to use that time to grade, or record work, or research on the internet, but what message does that send to the students in front of me when I tell them THEY must read, but I'm going to do this other task instead? If I value reading for them, I'd better be doing it myself also.

I also require students to read books -- not magazines. Real comprehension can't occur reading short magazine articles...at least the kind of comprehension I'm aiming for. We must wrestle with the text, being confused sometimes, but reading on to make sense. I'm open to any book, fiction or nonfiction, they'd like to read, but we deal in books.

Choice is vital. I give my students freedom to choose any book they want to read, and to abandon any book that's not working. I suggest they revisit books they read in middle school to find the beauty in the books they missed. I recommend Young Adult literature to my students, and have really worked hard over the years to expand my knowledge of YA books for boys. I recommend adult contemporary literature and classics. I recommend biographies and other nonfiction. Students are likely to hear about 20 to 30 books a week between my book shares and their classmates' book shares.

Getting to know students quickly helps me focus my recommendations to them. I learn their relative reading level and can match books within their comfort zone. I know their interests, I remember what they have read before and know other books like those.

I have probably 2000 books in my room, books I've collected over the years. I buy many new books, but I also haunt thrift shops, amazon.com used books, and I copy an idea from Kelly Gallagher and ask graduating seniors to consider donating a book to my collection. That helps students because we can browse and 'shop' right in my room. My librarians are highly supportive of the class and are valuable resources to kids who just need someone besides me to talk to.

Another element is the way I respond to their work. We read and we write. Students must write about their books. I absolutely understand 'fake reading.' I know most high school students are masters of the art and craft of fake reading...of being able to talk around the book without doing more than skimming. So, my Reading Logs are the heart of our work. They write about their questions, their predictions, their opinions. I ask them to connect their books to their lives. I have them find important quotes from the books and write about them.

But the real magic of the class happens as I read their Logs...I read every word. And I respond to every entry. I ask questions, I drop hints, I agree with observations...I respond the way readers respond to each other. I model the conversations we have. I make suggestions, I ask clarifying questions. I model predicting and connecting.

I love to return graded papers to my students. They put their books down and pick up their papers to see what I've said to them! They get disappointed if I don't have their papers back the next day because they value our conversations as much as I do. One former student told me how important my role as his audience was to his development as a reader and writer. I was grateful he noticed my hard work...and it is hard.

On the Spring '12 final students, students wrote the questions and I chose some as required questions to answer and others that were optional. One of the optional questions was: What would be the most compelling reason for other students to take this class? R4P isn’t a core class…why do you think the administration wants R4P in the course catalog? 

Here are their answers...I am so proud of my students' reflections!


  • The reason I chose this class initially was because it featured something I was already good at. And I know for a fact this class attracts lots of nerdy bookworms. It also attracts students who heard it was a blow-off class. Granted , it is easy. It was designed to be easy. But it’s not a blow-off. I think this is a good class to take because it gives students autonomy, at least for an hour. As you say, students get few choices in their education, so why pass up a choice when it is presented?
  • R4P is a good reminder that learning can be fun and more meaningful if it’s more about a focus on the students as individuals than number and tests scores. We could read what we wanted and write about what popped out to us and share what moved us, even if it wasn’t some classic that teens can’t relate to anymore…We aren’t really reading it [classics assigned in class], just waiting for the teacher to stop and explain or show us the movie.
  • In R4P we get to relax and read and discuss our thoughts
  • At the beginning of the semester I could barely read 15 pages a day because I could barely focus. Now I can sit and read for an hour. R4P has helped me in English class because it has raised my focus level
  • Considering I rarely ever read before I took this class, I’d say I expanded my reading a lot by just learning how to love reading
  • Going to classes throughout the day that drain you mentally sometimes runs you down. R4P is a class where you can still be stimulating your mind but you are doing it in a way where you are relaxed and enjoying what you are doing.
  • Honestly before R4P I did not think I would ever appreciate a novel of any kind. I now walk away from class with an entirely new perspective on novels
  • I can now focus much longer while reading without becoming distracted or zoning out. This class has helped me to learn to like reading. Before this class I never read for pleasure, nor ever had the desire to read at all
  • I have read 17 books in ONE class during ONE semester. If I wasn’t a good reader, that wouldn’t have been possible
  • I think others should take R4P because you can express yourself and you’re not forced to read any certain book
  • I think students take this class because they get to choose what they read. There’s no requirements, and therefore, more freedoms.
  • I used to hate reading, but I actually read at home now. I’m proud to say even as much as I have never thought I would be, I am a reader
  • I would suggest this class for kids who don’t like reading, but once they get in the class and find a good book their lives will be changed.
  • I’m proud…I have made a complete 180 turn as a reader in every way
  • If you love reading, R4P is already perfect for you because it offers you time to do what you love. If you don’t like reading, R4P teaches you to love reading a lot.
  • In R4P I took chances with books I would have never given a second glance before and I actually do like them.
  • In R4P if you don’t enjoy reading, you learn why you don’t and most likely, you’ll overcome that and discover your inner reader
  • In R4P you jump into the books and get to experience things you never thought possible
  • It doesn’t feel like mandatory reading in here.
  • More time to read…sharpens critical thinking, vocabulary, writing and analysis skills
  • R4P allowed me to relax. Before this class, I was always stressed with work and other classes. R4P was a miracle for me and I don’t know where I would be without it.
  • R4P has helped me most with reading comprehension. As a reader, I find myself more confident in my ability to comprehend literature. I get a sense of pride from R4P
  • R4P has helped me stay more focused and also helped with speaking in front of people. It has shown me that if I open myself up to something new I might actually like it and learn something.
  • R4P has helped me to become a more efficient, faster and careful reader when it comes to school work. It has shown me the progress I’ve made in my reading speed and examining skills…When I go back and read my journals, I feel very accomplished and proud of my writing skills.
  • R4P has helped me to become more mature. I’m more ready to open up and try new things. I’m still as picky as ever, but at least I can get through a boring book. Is that stamina? I suppose.
  • R4P has helped me to stay focused and engaged in other classes when I really didn’t want to.
  • R4P has shown me I can read anything if I put my mind to it.
  • R4P has shown me I can read however I want and I need to throw away the excuses. I get clarity out of reading when my thoughts are jumbled, I can see the silver lining with books.
  • R4P has shown me that I can understand more than one genre, and reminded me of my love for reading…you get to learn your favorite genre of book, learn how to respond to the books and see where you’re at as a reader.
  • R4P has shown me that I’m actually a pretty good reader. I’m better than I thought I was
  • R4P has taught me to give every book a chance.
  • R4P helped me in other classes, especially History, because it got easier for me to read through the information and it got easier to comprehend what’s going in, so I did better in that class.
  • R4P helps people get better in reading and in R4P you almost never have homework so it’s helpful and easy…it can’t get much better than that.
  • R4P helps you read faster, take notes faster, and generally get your work done in time.
  • R4P is a class with more than one teacher because if students keep reading diligently they may find that they are learning twenty different lessons from twenty different teachers, as opposed to one subject by a single teacher.
  • R4P is a good reminder that learning can be fun and more meaningful if it’s more about a focus on students as individuals than number and test scores.
  • R4P is such a peaceful, happy part of my day
  • R4P not only gives you time to read it makes you feel like you’re in a different universe
  • R4P showed me that I CAN sit and read a book for an hour and love it. I get enjoyment out of reading. I also gain knowledge and extend my vocabulary by reading books with words I have not learned
  • R4P’s a great class to just sit back, crack open a book you want to read and just reeellaax. I man any book you might want to read. Boom! Come here, sit down, and read.
  • Students should take this class to build speed and stamina
  • Taking R4P will help you stay put and be able to read, which will help you when you have to read textbooks and things
  • The most compelling reason for students to take R4P is the freedom
  • The most compelling reason for students to take this class is that you get to read and discuss books in school that you want to read. Talking to someone else about a book that you really like is one of the best feelings ever. And for that person to be a teacher that has a degree in what she’s talking about, can only improve your thoughts about a book.
  • The most compelling reason for taking this class is that you get a grade for reading and you never get called [out] for reading while the teacher is lecturing
  • The most compelling reason to take R4P is that it truly is for everyone. There’s a book for EVERYONE no matter who you are.
  • This class offers so much like the opportunity to discover who you are in reading, a fun atmosphere…it is a class to grow as an individual and become confident in your reading ability
  • This class shows kids that gook books to exist. This class forces kids to find something they like in a book
  • This class teaches you something necessary for college and life, to read…and to enjoy reading
  • We could read what we wanted and write about what popped out to us and share what moved us, even if it wasn’t some classic that teens can’t relate to anymore
  • We have the freedom to choose what we learn about in R4P
  • Writing my thoughts and how I feel about what I’m reading made me connect more to the characters. I’m not just reading to get my assignment done
  • You take in knowledge of your choice in a relaxed environment


Saturday, November 3, 2012

Changin' Minds About Reading...one day at a time

I recently read the Pew Report about reading habits of young people and chuckled at the stats: 83% of adolescents and young people surveyed had read a book last year. We as a nation should be pleased that young adults are reading and using libraries. As an English teacher, a reading specialist and a library media specialist, I have a vested interest in encouraging students to read.

My first response to the report was, 'How sad. Only one?' In my Reading for Pleasure class I have my students keep track of their reading -- books and pages, and I would consider it a personal defeat, a Waterloo, if any of my students ONLY read one book during my class, and it's only 18 weeks long. In fact, I just had students report their reading as part of their midterm self-reflections. I wanted them to feel personal pride at their accomplishments, and the Pew report gave me a baseline number for them all to compare themselves to.

As I reported the final-ish (as final as you can ever have when dealing with 155 high school students) numbers...I ended up with numbers from 146 of them. 146 students read 860.9524 books -- in NINE WEEKS! They read 264,585 pages! As I did the big reveal in all of the classes, I asked for drumrolls and students happily complied. If anyone's interested, that's an average of 5.8969342...and a bunch more numbers behind the decimal.

Now, it always surprised people when I tell them not all of my students love reading...at first. I have a survey question I ask at the beginning of the semester and again on the final exam about how they feel about reading...choices range from LOVE IT to HATE IT. I usually compile the information and file it for myself, but this year I tried something different. I gave all my students sticky notes and asked them to write JUST their class period, not their name...and to place it on the white board at the back of my room under the description that best fits the way they feel about reading. I didn't watch them so they could be completely honest. Kids end up in my class for many reasons -- including a forced placement by parents or counselors or special education teachers. I hope my openness to their honesty helps them know I'm happy they're in class and will work with them at whatever their current attitude is.


We watched our chart take form for a couple of days and then I asked the students to observe and write what they see. Many kids identified the five outliers who HATE reading as well as the two who hate it, and noticed they all came from my first and second hour classes. They noticed that the biggest category was 'OK if I choose.' I noticed it looks like a lopsided bell curve, with most answers in those middle categories. I asked then to tell me what this chart says about my job and their jobs. Students saw my job for the semester to be moving everyone forward (to the west from the orientation of my room)...No one expected attitudes to change much, but, students identified my job and theirs for the semester: work together, be positive role models. Share books, have a great attitude. I was proud of how many students took ownership of the task before us -- help everyone leave class in January with a positive attitude about reading. As the grown-up in the room, I knew a positive attitude would also reflect heightened confidence, stronger reading skills, and more reading stamina. That's my secret, though...I tell my students I'm working strictly on their attitudes about reading.

So, last week was the end of the first nine weeks -- midterm. I have a midterm reflection I ask students to complete...I want them to review their goals for the semester, examine their writing about books, and think about their attitude and if it's changing. So, I took off all the stickies and had students recreate our chart about reading attitudes. Again, I didn't look...but in my first hour, one of my students told me he was one of the HATE IT's from the first week, but is slowly (!) changing his mind...he asked could he create a new description: "Mraw" to be placed between HATE IT and hate it...a real victory! He's found a couple of books he likes but isn't willing to fall into books yet.

Next week, I'll have students examine this chart and tell me what stands out to them...I see that movement to the west I need...I see more students now like reading, without the qualifier of 'if I choose.' They've had nine weeks to choose, to abandon, to sample. They've had nine weeks of recommendations from me and from classmates. They've started their 'books to read next' lists. They've been surrounded by books and by people who are reading. They've written reflections of their books and had authentic conversations with me and others about their books.

The distribution is no longer a bell, with more stickies placed in those positive attitude columns. Even my students who entered my classroom in August with surly attitudes about reading have found success and along the way have found confidence. Success and confidence are contagious -- you catch them in Reading for Pleasure.

Now, I need those three outliers to move one more 'category' for the final exam! 

Tuesday, May 13, 2014

Horton and Ma and Pa Ingalls Held Hostage by Janet Costello Baressi, DDS

Janet Costello Baressi, DDS, must be a skilled dentist. She has been successful, and her own smile is lovely. I would never presume to critique her work, or to offer suggestions.

I am a reading specialist, with 39 years of teaching experience, K-12, and college level adjunct work. I have taught remedial reading classes in elementary and secondary settings. I offer this as my credentials.  I am an NBCT, with current certification in English Language Arts, Reading Specialist, Library Media, Yearbook (we all have yearbook certification) and World History (don’t ask!!). I am qualified to speak to DDS Baressi’s remarks about reading and reading instruction.

I attended the House debate and vote yesterday for HB2625, which amends the current RSA, giving parents and teachers a voice in the promotion or retention of their students. It was eye-opening, and gratifying to see the House join the Senate in overwhelmingly supporting parents and their rights to be involved in their own children’s education. There was a slight hiccup when Representative Nelson tried to include his voucher bill, but he lost big, and spent the rest of the afternoon sniping and posturing.

DDS Baressi was disappointed that the House and Senate both voted to substantially change her signature bill, the 3rd Grade Flunk law by having the temerity to include parents and teachers on a committee that will make retention decisions. She holds complete faith in a test to do that job, and she isn’t shy about telling us so.
Her press release, offered less than 20 minutes after the final vote in the House, eeirely echoed the words of Representative Nelson in the House Chambers – that this bill will promote social promotion. I wonder if they were working from the same page.

DDS Baressi, in her own words:

Illiteracy in our children must be a call to action. 

Did she just call our kids illiterates? Our nine-year-olds, who have been practicing their reading skills for just a few years? Kids who are still learning the complexities of taking meaning off the page?

“The RSA ensures the greatest resources and amount of time available to intensive, customized reading instruction.

No, the RSA provides fewer than $100 per child for remediation…for supplies, resources, professional development, and tutoring costs. Florida, which is the originator of this idea, funds their version with tens of thousands of dollars, every year. Once again, Oklahoma is mandating on the cheap, on the backs of our kids and teachers.

The point of the RSA is to focus education for struggling readers long before they reach third-grade.

I highly resent her implications that teachers weren’t focusing on struggling readers before her magic-pill law. I’ve worked with elementary teachers…they are heroes of epic proportions. They respect and honor the complex work of learning. Every day they create magic.



Instead of providing an alternative to learning to read, which this pending bill does, we should instead spend our energies helping these students read.

“Alternative to learning to read?” What is an alternative to learning to read? Reading takes time. Not all of us learn in the same way, at the same time. Representative Henke pointed that out in her remarks in the House Chambers: “All kids learn differently.” Those of us who cheered and applauded were reprimanded…no displays in the Chambers…but applaud we did.

Instead of taking the easy way out, we need to make certain every effort is made by parents, teachers and our communities to help these children learn to read.”

Remember, this bill gives parents a place at the table when making decisions about their own children’s education, something DDS Baressi and Representative Nelson  scream to the housetops when it involves charters and vouchers. But parents’ rights for public school parents? That’s the ‘easy way out.’ That’s somehow thwarting a child’s education. To quote Representative Inman, “I’m sick of this rhetoric.”

House Bill 2625 reinforces a status quo that has failed far too many children.

You know, the real status quo is the current testing climate. Over ten years of NCLB, and now RttT, has created this new status quo: high stakes testing attached to everything in school. Now kids are failed and refused diplomas because of test scores. Now schools and districts are graded on test scores. Soon teachers will be evaluated on test scores. THAT is the status quo, and I absolutely agree – this status quo is failing children. I don’t think she knows what that phrase really means.

It places exorbitant costs and time on school districts by mandating fourth- and fifth-grade reading remediation for students with Unsatisfactory and Limited Knowledge scores.
NOW she cares about costs to schools? Oh Puleese! This is the same woman who suggests districts pay a raise for teachers out of their carry over funds. Now she cares??

It undermines a law that districts have had three years to comply with and involve parents in its implementation.

I’m intrigued by that last statement. Is she saying parents were involved in the implementing of the current law? Are they like those mythical teachers who wrote CCSS standards? Parents, please let me know if you were consulted and involved in this bill. I’d love to know more.

Before the vote, State Superintendent Janet Barresi said Monday if a third grader can’t read first-grade level Dr. Seuss books, fourth grade books like “Little House On The Prairie” are really going to frustrate a child.

BUT what really chapped me, the reading specialist, the reading teacher, is this, her insistence that the current RSA and the current test actually tests reading levels. First, the test she is bound to, the test she wants to flunk kids with is NOT a reading test. It’s a hybrid reading-language arts test…with vocabulary questions, literary elements questions, and reference questions. Second, the test cannot (I repeat CANNOT) give us reading levels. Her cute visuals of the books is bogus. This test does not give reading levels, something a reading test could. And third, instead of reading levels, this test is one that can be manipulated by politicians and policy makers. The score for ‘proficient’ the cut score is set, by a committee, or not. The score moves from year to year, at the whims of people far removed from the children and the teachers whose lives are affected by the scores.



Back to Horton and Ma and Pa Ingalls. She identifies Horton as a first grade level, and Little House as a fourth. Jason James, who has written extensively about the third grade reading-language arts test, points out DDS Baressi’s two examples are really closer in grade level than she realized. Not a surprise…she is a dentist, not an educator.

This is not the first time she’s waded into the reading arena unarmed with any facts. In an appearance before of stalwart GOP loyalists, she tried tostart the Reading Wars again, bringing up the dreaded ‘Whole Language’ readingmethods.

She says the children retained because of their test scores do not actually “repeat” third grade, they only take reading classes to catch up.
I’m completely baffled by this assertion. Kids won’t be repeating third grade? They’ll actually be in fourth grade, trekking down the hall to take reading instruction? What?
Representative Reynolds, in an act of complete brazenness, asserted strongly that he knows kids are “more likely to learn to read with other kids who read at the same level.” I muttered under my breath (I hope), “RESEARCH??” He later said he didn’t need research, since he had stories of how retention is good for kids…he must not have gotten the memo that this will NOT retain kids in third grade…NONE of us did.
Barresi said, “For those few children that don’t qualify under these exemptions, then let’s just stop as a state and say ‘let’s give you the gift of reading’.”
Gag me now. Just gag me. 7970 third graders did not pass the reading-language arts test. 7970 children were told they are not good enough, and won’t pass. Henke in her remarks in the House quoted a figure of 2%-3% of these 7970 children will qualify for a ‘good cause exemption’ and be promoted. Who am I going to believe? Not the dentist.

IF we’re not retaining these kids, as she said above, why are we ‘stopping?’

I couldn’t find evidence that yesterday she used her patented line, ‘Learning to read vs reading to learn.’ I think my head might have exploded. As it was, more than once yesterday, I was ready to launch myself over the railing in the balcony of the House, to confront a stupidity uttered as truth by one Legislator or another.

DDS Baressi is on the wrong side of this argument. The parents, grandparents, teachers of those 7970 children are on the right side. While her words are practiced and smooth, her skills are not those of an educator. She is tied to a policy that will continue to fail our children. She must put Horton and the Ingalls back on the shelf and find a way to work with the legislators and parents who have stood up to her and said, enough.